Who is Ariel Castro?
Is he the affable guy who would wave to neighbors, talk with them about his Harley and the little girl he sometimes walked with? Is he a longtime bus driver who'd sometimes eat ribs with neighbors on the porch of his two-story home while listening to salsa music? Is he an upbeat man who loved music, impressing his bandmates with his talent and smile?
Or is Ariel Castro a cold-hearted abductor?
His Cleveland neighbors are trying to come with grips with the two personas -- the first, the Ariel Castro they thought they knew, the other, the one that authorities describe.
Police say Castro held three young women against their will for years in his home. Their captivity ended on Monday, when Amanda Berry -- who had been missing for a decade -- attracted the attention of a neighbor, who helped her, Georgina "Gina" DeJesus and Michelle Knight escape. A 6-year-old girl that police said is believed to be Berry's daughter also was freed.
A short time later, the 52-year-old Ariel Castro was arrested as were two of his brothers, Pedro and Onil Castro.
All three spent Tuesday night behind bars, but Ariel Castro's two brothers won't be charged, said Victor Perez, chief assistant prosecutor for the city of Cleveland. On Wednesday, Perez said authorities have found "no evidence" that Pedro and Onil Castro were complicit. Ariel Castro, however, faces charges on four counts of kidnapping and three counts of rape, Perez said.
This week, Castro's neighbors were asking themselves not only who this man was but also whether they could have done anything to stop the horrors he is accused of.
One of them, Daniel Marti, has known Ariel Castro since junior high school and lived near him for about 22 years. He thought Castro was an "outgoing person, very nice guy."
But looking back -- like many of his neighbors -- Marti can't shake a few things. Like how Castro always seemed to lead him away from his house when they talked. Or how Castro would go to McDonald's most everyday and bring back bags of food, all for a bachelor who everyone believed lived alone. Or about the child Castro sometimes went out with, brought back home, only to head out later without the girl, whom he'd left behind.
"So really he was fooling us," Marti said, convinced that Castro isn't the nice neighbor he'd thought. "He made a fool out of all of us."
Talked of children, grandchildren
Born in Puerto Rico, Ariel Castro moved to Ohio as a child, his uncle Julio Castro said.
About two decades ago, Marti recalled that Castro went through a messy breakup. In 1993, court records show that he was arrested on a domestic violence charge, which was later dropped.
Then, in 2005, he was accused of repeated abuse and domestic violence by his common-law wife, Grimilda Figueroa, according to court documents.
Figueroa accused Castro of several acts of domestic violence: two broken noses, broken ribs, a knocked-out tooth, a blood clot on the brain, and lacerations, court papers said. She also suffered two dislocated shoulders, once to each side, documents said.
Figueroa alleged Castro "threatened to kill" her and their daughters on three or four occasions in 2005, court papers said. Castro's relationship to Figueroa is listed as "father to children," but only two of Figueroa's three children -- both daughters -- have the Castro surname, court papers said. The other child is a boy.
Figueroa also accused Castro of frequently abducting their daughters and keeping them from her, documents said.
The court granted her an order of protection on August 29, 2005, the same day she filed the court documents. Figueroa asked the court to send Castro to batterer and substance abuse counseling.
But on November 23, 2005, the court set aside the protection order. A court official familiar with the case told CNN that the order couldn't have been dismissed without all parties agreeing to it.
After numerous court appearances by the wife where Castro did not show up, on the big day of the hearing, Castro and his lawyer were present but Figueroa's lawyer couldn't be present, the court official said. The parties decided she was at a disadvantage without him and ultimately the case was dismissed, the court official added.
Later, another of Ariel Castro's daughters, Emily Castro, was found guilty but mentally ill of cutting her 11-month-old daughter four times on the neck in April 2007. Emily Castro, 19 at the time, is now serving a 25-year sentence for attempted murder in an Indiana prison.
In recent years, Castro seemed to live alone, except for occasional visits by, among others, his two brothers.
The man who helped rescue Berry, Charles Ramsey, told reporters the suspect wasn't known around the neighborhood for anything exciting.
"We see this dude every day. I've been here a year. I barbecued with this dude. We eat ribs and listen to salsa music," Ramsey said.